Detergent vs Non Detergent Oil

Written by

Charles Bolte


Vernon Hoppe 

detergent vs non detergent oil

Between the 2 choices of detergent vs non detergent oil, which do you think is the right option to use? Before anything else, it would be best to understand their differences.

The most common explanation is detergent oil contains additives that ensure anti-sludge. This factor helps collect the grime and debris more easily into the oil filter for a cleaner lubrication system.

For a more in-depth explanation, let’s check the comparison below for non detergent oil vs detergent!

Detergent Non-Detergent
– Contain additives

– Longer oil performance

– Used in engine with oil circulation system

– Ideal for modern motorcycles

– Perform acid neutralization, sludge breakdown, and rust prevention

– Doesn’t contain additives

– More frequent oil change needed

– Used for lawn mowers or 2-stroke engine

– Collects contaminants to keep them from clinging to the sidewalls

– Compatible with older automobiles and engines that have not been refurbished


Aside from the common knowledge discussed above, it is also important to know the applicable circumstances of when to use detergent oil or the other. Or better yet, the best time to switch is when it is applicable.

These are vital points to consider as a vehicle owner and user of small engine, gas-powered appliances like a lawn mower. As you know, motor oil is the lubrication required to make them work properly and efficiently. Thus, making the right choice is a must.

You might have heard of using high detergent motor oil for small engines, but it’s not the only viable option. Non-detergent is a common choice for such engines. For a clearer discussion, let’s discuss every factor below!

1. About Detergent Oil

With the risk of engine failure from the grime, debris, and other deposits, product prevention is the best way to go. That’s why engine oil detergent is the perfect choice.

  • Detergents in oil are the additive activated that keeps control of the acidic contaminants during combustion. It is also vital for controlling deposits of residue from high temperatures.
  • These capabilities will prevent clogging problems and are proven to work due to the other chemicals in the formulation. Such effects are beneficial for a cleaner operation, making oil change schedules less frequent.
  • Furthermore, using detergent oil ensures smooth and clean engine It’s the reason why it becomes the perfect choice for engines of today. The common

With such undeniable advantages, detergent oil is a great choice for longevity, performance quality, and accessibility.

2. About Non-Detergent Oil

Meanwhile, non-detergent oil is the counterpart, which might be an untimely type to use nowadays. That’s because engines that comply with the API classification of SA and SB are only compatible with this oil type. In short, it is not preferable for engines made after 1963.

Given that the standard oils for modern engines have cleaning additives, this oil type might not be functional enough.

According to a source, non-detergent oil lacks the additive for eliminating the contaminants. However, it acts as a magnet, attracting particles that lead to sludge formation. This factor is present to prevent the contaminants from sticking to the walls.

Despite lacking the cleaning factor, it still functions as a lubricator. It is a suitable choice for lawnmowers due to lesser time of usage than vehicles.

The common non-detergent oils today are the following:

  • Turbine Oil
  • Oxidation and rust oil
  • Multipurpose oil

Overall, it shows that non-detergent oil is also a competitive product. It can offer possible operations and effectiveness, with the drawback of the longevity area.

How to Tell if Oil is Detergent or Non-Detergent?


Aside from the discussed pros and cons, understanding their differences will also help identify the better option. Checking this part is vital for everyone who plans on buying either of them because the wrong item will result in damages.

So, to avoid such problematic situations, follow the tips below!

1. Check the Label

This tip is the easiest way to identify which is which. According to an article, some of the oils have an identification on either the container or box. It is mostly common for non-detergent oil.

2. Examine the Appearance of the Oil

Meanwhile, another way to differentiate them is through the oil’s appearance. Usually, detergent oil will appear darker due to the included additives, while non-detergent is clearer.

Can I Switch From Non-Detergent to Detergent Oils?

Switching from non-detergent to detergent oil may severely damage your engine, causing sludge to be released and damaging cam shafts, bearings, and rods.

Before deciding on mixing detergent and non-detergent oil, it is vital to check whether the machinery involved won’t suffer from the shift in oil.

Both types of oil can offer reliable functions to lubricate the engine. However, they don’t provide the same service. For instance, the formed sludge from using non-detergent may cause a problem once switched to detergent oil.

For safer machinery usage, it would be best to stick with the oil catered for engine type and other classifications mentioned in the discussion earlier. You can also contact a mechanic to help with the oil change and to consult whether or not it is applicable to use a different oil.


When deciding which from the detergent vs non detergent oil is the best oil, the answer might be trivial for many. However, it seems there’s no right and wrong answer, as long as the chosen oil is used in the suitable engine.

Both are competitive at their own game and can be used well. However, when choosing a suitable oil, the best way to handle it is to check your vehicle’s manual. From that info, choose the oil that best suits the engine, and everything will work well.

Rate this post
Categories Oil

Magazine Latest Posts

Who Makes Quaker State Oil

Who Makes Quaker State Oil?

Have you heard about the Quaker State oil products? If yes, you might have thought ...


Is Marvel Mystery Oil Good?

  When was the last time you used a fuel or oil additive? If you ...

Predator 212 Oil Type & Capacity

Predator 212 Oil Type & Capacity

Whether used for go-karting or generating, choosing the right Predator 212 oil type & capacity ...

Quaker State vs Pennzoil

Quaker State vs Pennzoil: A Quick Comparsion

Quaker State Vs Pennzoil? Choosing the right engine oil from the same brand can be ...

How Tight Should an Oil Filter Be

How Tight Should an Oil Filter Be? How to Tighten Properly?

An oil filter is essential in maintaining the overall condition of your car engine, as ...

Is Havoline Good Oil

Is Havoline Good Oil? (Pros & Cons, Performance and More)

Havoline is a popular motor oil brand with great products that offer adequate engine protection. ...